UNDER CONSTRUCTION!

This is a free analysis generated by recording submitted to me by one of my subscribers.

Contact Me Now if you would like a free analysis of one of your temperaments.

Piano: Newcombe Console
Submitted by: 005

A440: 20%

Criteria: No marks lost if 0.9 cents off, or less. Lose 4 marks for every 0.1 cent off after that. Minimum pass is 80%.

A4 Source = 440.2 Hz (0.9 cents from A440)
A4 = 439.5 Hz (-2.0 cents)
Difference = 2.9 cents

We use F2 to create beats with A4 and A440.
We try to tune A4 so that the beats created by F2A4 are the same speed as those created by F2A440.
F2 creates beats because it is flat from pure with A4 and A440.
If the beats are the same speed, then A4 and A440 are the same amount sharp of the fifth partial of F2, and therefore A4 = A440.
Click the filtered buttons to hear the beating A4 easier.
The faster beating pair indicates the sharper A4 or A440.

F3F4 and A3A4 Octaves

A3A4: 50%

= 7.6 bps
= 5.5 bps

Size of 4:2 A3A4: Narrow (29%)

= 13 bps
= 10 bps

Size of 6:3 A3A4: Narrow (24%)

F3F4: 100%

= 8.3 bps
= 7.9 bps

Size of 4:2 F3F4: "Pure" 4:2 (5% narrow)

= 8.7 bps
= 9.6 bps

Size of 6:3 F3F4: Wide (11%)

Comments on the Octaves F3F4 and A3A4

Both octaves are narrow. The 4:2 and 6:3 are both narrow for each octave.

When you click the F3F4 and A3A4 buttons, you can hear a slight roll in the upper partials.

Notice that the 4:2's are less narrow than the 6:3's. This implies that the piano may have Medium Scaled Octaves, that could be tuned as wide 4:2/narrow 6:3.

It is also possible that they are close enough in size (the 4:2's and the 6:3's) that the octaves may be tuned as pure 4:2/pure 6:3, each within 3%, and then we would identify this piano as having Small Scale Octaves.

---

CHROMATIC LADDERS

GRADING OF THE TEMPERAMENT

I have designed two different grading schemes for measuring temperaments.

One is based on the error of the frequencies relative to a master tuning. This method is similar to the Registered Piano Technicians exam administered by the Piano Technicians Guild. The "master tuning" is determined by those frequencies that would produce beat speeds that increase by the same ratio as the average ratio of the actual beat speeds.

The second method assigns a penalty for each beat speed that does not fall within a certain limit. M3's must increase by 0 to 10%. P4's must beat between 0.5 and 1.5 beats per second.

Below are the marks calculated by each method. The PTG requires a minimum mark of 80% in many of its exams.

Temperament Mark

Average Ratio Method: 84%
(Similar to RPT method)

Beat Speed Limit Method: 79%
(Represents more directly what the tuner can hear. Preferred method.)

M3 BEAT SPEED PROGRESSIONS

HOW TO USE THE M3 GRAPHS

M3 intervals should increase speed chromatically as smoothly as possible.

1.Listen to the recordings below and look at the graph.

2.Listen to the filtered recording and try to confirm aurally that speeds are following what the graph says. This improves your Beat Speed Ratio Sensitivity.

3.Listen to the unfiltered recording and try to confirm aurally that speeds are following what the graph says. This improves your Beat Speed Clarity - the ability to hear beat speeds clearly.

M3, filtered:

M3, unfiltered:

---

P4 BEAT SPEED PROGRESSIONS

HOW TO USE THE P4 GRAPH

P4 intervals should beat close to 1 bps.

1.Listen to the recordings below while looking at the graph.

2.Listen to the filtered recording and try to confirm aurally that speeds are following what the graph says. This improves your Beat Speed Ratio Sensitivity.

3.Listen to the unfiltered recording and try to hear the quality of a tuned P4 (1 bps), a pure P4 (0 bps), and an out of tune P4 (>1.5 bps). Identifying correct and incorrect P4's are a very powerful refinement tool.

P4, filtered

P4, unfiltered

---

INSIGHT

You must understand interval sizes in Equal Temperament, and Wide, Narrow, and Pure Intervals, in order to follow the logic explained below.

The logic used is to find a M3 that does not progress smoothly, and then find a P4 that confirms which note needs correction.

Specific Comments

While the M3's seem to progress relatively smoothly, except for the last one, The P4's are all on the fast side, except for the last one.

The obvious places to look for confirmation of corrections needed, are the fast C4E4 and the fast B3E4

C4E4 is too fast. C4 is low and/or E4 is high.
B3E4 is too fast. B3 is low and/or E4 is high.
E4 is high.

C#4F4 is too slow. C#4 is high and/or F4 is low.
C4F4 is too slow. C4 is high and/or F4 is low.
F4 is low

FURTHER CONFIRMATION

Try to hear the following inconsistencies in the following chromatic ladders. These are predicted by the findings above.

Chromatic M6's:
F3D4/F#3D#4/G3E4/G#3F4
1. E4 is too high. G3E4 should sound too fast.
2. F4 is too low. G#3F4 should sound too slow.

Chromatic P5's:
F3C4/F#3C#4/G3D4/G#3D#4/A3E4/A#3F4
1. E4 is high. A3E4 may sound too pure, or be wide.
2. F4 is low. A#3F4 should sound too narrow.

Chromatic m3's:
F3G#3/F#3A3/G3A#3/G#3B3/A3C4/A#3C#4/B3D4/C4D#4/C#4E4/D4F4
1. E4 is high. C#4E4 should sound too slow.
2. F4 is low. D4F4 should sound too fast.
Chromatic m6's:
F3C#4/F#3D4/G3D#4/G#3E4/A3F4
1. E4 is high. G#3E4 should sound too slow.
2. F4 is low. A3F4 should sound too fast.

Compare the above intervals with their neighbours.

Notice how we identify two problems that have the same note, and then look for a way to change that note and fix both problems. This reiterative method helps us improve the temperament bit by bit.

This is why it is imperative that, if you want to improve your aural tuning, you must improve your beat speed recognition. Exercises like these can help greatly.

You are encouraged to read the analysis and confirm aurally that you can hear the findings, and understand how the improvements suggested would improve the beat speed progressions.

In this way you will improve your ear and be able to hear smaller differences in beat speeds, which will ultimately improve your temperament.

Please leave a comment